Skip to main content

ALBUM REVIEW: "One More Light" by Linkin Park

  Linkin Park have always had an interesting relationship with their fans; with every album since 2003's Hybrid Theory they have shifted and moved away from whatever they did before, often testing the patience of even their most die-hard fans. Since their early rap infused nu-metal days they have explored more straight forward rock and even touched on the U2 bag of tricks on Minutes To Midnight, thrown a curve ball and dived into more experimental (some would say pretentious) electronic territory on A Thousand Suns, they have sounded like a watered down Nine Inch Nails on Living Things, and took a tentative step back into their guitar-based past on The Hunting Party. While I am certainly not the same die-hard Linkin Park fan I was at 14, I can appreciate from a distance the way they have continued to do whatever the hell they want with their music, obviously without any regard for what they think will please the most people. At this stage, then, it is difficult to pin down exactly what Linkin Park's sound is. This is only compounded with the release of One More Light, and this is easily the biggest curve ball the band has thrown to date - more drastic a change than was had between Minutes To Midnight and A Thousand Suns. This is one of the biggest problems with this record; coming after The Hunting Party there is almost nothing of that band present here, and the transition is incredibly jarring. While at the same time I know I have no authority to say this, I think this would work a lot better if it weren't labelled as a Linkin Park album. It just seems to detached from anything else they have done in the past that it is incredibly difficult to come to terms with. I guess going in without any expectations would help, but when your band is approaching 20 years that is nearly impossible. It's not the lack of guitars and the prominence of keyboards, synths and slick production that's the problem (this has been done before with somewhat ok results and has been proven by other bands of similar pedigree to be viable options), instead a seeming lack of intent in the songwriting in general. On A Thousand Suns and Living Things there were at least interesting songs with progression and (depending on how widely you listen) a few fresh ideas. One More Light just didn't do it for me even on that level of "I wonder what comes next". When an album is only 35 minutes and I find myself constantly checking to see if I was getting through it, that is never a good thing. I'm not going to be one of those guys that will jump behind their keyboard and vent about how Linkin Park owe their fans better and that they've "sold out" - I don't really care about Linkin Park enough anymore to feel like that strongly about anything they do. For me it's more that One More Light approaches a corner of music that I've never been a huge fan of anyway (but have found my own favourites within) and does a consistently ok job of it. I'm also not going to bash One More Light, because there isn't anything really, really bad about it (there are a smattering of truly cringe-worthy lines on a number of songs, though). There's just nothing at all for me to grab ahold of and enjoy. At all. I don't remember any of the choruses, the production was ok but not overly dynamic, and... well, that's it really, there just isn't anything of note about One More Light. Good on them for not feeling they need to conform to their fans' expectations, I guess, but not really sure how they thought this would attract new fans if keeping the old ones wasn't a priority.

   Favourite Song: Sorry For Now 

    Least Favourite Song: ... look none of them are great.

   Rating: D

   What did you think? Did you like this album? Did you hate it? Let me know in the comments.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A Response To 'Christian' Views On Secular Music

Is there such thing as music that Christians shouldn’t listen to? Should we be dismissive of music with either explicit language or sexual, violent or substance oriented themes? Should anyone even be telling anyone else what they can and can’t listen to? These are questions that are thrown around a lot in Christian circles, and given what I do here on this blog and how that overlaps with my job working for the church, I thought I would share my thoughts on this topic. I’ll say this at the outset so that we’re on the same page – I think any attempt to dictate what people should and shouldn’t listen to is stupid and disrespectful on a fundamental level. I’ll go into detail about why I think that later on, but for now here are some thoughts I have on some of the “Christian” opinions I come across pretty regularly. The first and most ludicrous thing that seems to follow me around is the idea that because I listen to underground genres, particularly on the heavy metal ...
2 comments
Read more

1 YEAR LATER: "22, A Million" by Bon Iver

   Bon Iver's third studio album turns 1 in about a week (where did that year go?), so I thought it would be interesting to talk a bit about how my impressions of the album have changed - or how they haven't - over the last 12 months. When this album was released I was more excited than I think I ever have been to hear a new album. For Emma, Forever Ago is one of my all time favourites, and I love his self-titled second album too, so I had huge expectations for this album, but was also wary that expectations might ruin my experience of the music. This was particularly the case for 22, A Million , because it is unlike anything else Justin Vernon has released. There have been hints at this more processed, electronic direction previously, like the song "Woods" on the Blood Bank EP and occasional flourishes on Bon Iver , but 22, A Million is a drastic departure from the Bon Iver sound we had grown accustomed to at this point in time. Or at least, that's what I thought...
Post a Comment
Read more

Should Brand New be in my top 20? (CONTENT WARNING: sexual abuse)

    For those who read both top 20 albums lists that I did - one here on thatmusicnerd and one over at Kill Your Stereo - you will have noticed, I'm sure, that one had The Ongoing Concept's album Places at number 1, and the other had Brand New's Science Fiction at the top. Full disclosure, I initially had Brand New at the top of just the one list, but the readership of Kill Your Stereo reacted very strongly against the allegations of sexual misconduct against Brand New frontman Jesse Lacey and so I removed it entirely. In fact, none of the  KYS contributors' top 20 lists featured Science Fiction at all. Of course I was happy to follow the general consensus in regards to whether or not an artist accused of such things should be promoted by a music publication, but I still stand by my opinion that Science Fiction was the best album of 2017 and as such it was number 1 on my thatmusicnerd top 20 list.    2017 has been a pretty crazy year in terms of the ...
Post a Comment
Read more